I’ll admit, I was skeptical when I first heard about The Original Makeup Eraser.
A cloth that removes all your makeup with just water? Come on. I’ve tried enough beauty products to know when something sounds too good to be true.
But this thing kept popping up everywhere. My friends were raving about it. Beauty bloggers wouldn’t stop talking about it. So I had to find out what’s really going on.
I spent hours reading real user reviews, testing claims, and getting the full story. Does it actually work like they say? What are the catches? And honestly, is it worth your money? Let me share what I found.
What Is The Original Makeup Eraser?
The Original Makeup Eraser is a reusable cloth that removes makeup with just water. No cleansers, no chemicals needed.
Here’s What It Does
Wet the cloth with warm water and wipe your face. The special fibers grab onto makeup and lift it away from your skin. When it gets dirty, throw it in the washing machine. One cloth can last for thousands of uses.
The company says it works on all makeup types and is safe for sensitive skin.
Why People Love It
It’s simple. You save money on makeup remover. You create less waste since you’re not tossing cotton pads daily. And if harsh ingredients bother your skin, this removes that worry completely.
For someone who just wants to wash their face and go to bed, it’s an easy solution.
How Does the Makeup Eraser Work?
The secret is in the microfiber material. These aren’t your regular cloth fibers. They’re super thin and woven in a way that creates tiny spaces.
When you wet the cloth and rub it on your skin, these fibers grab onto makeup, dirt, and oil, pulling them away from your face.
How to Use It
It’s pretty straightforward. Wet the cloth with warm water until it’s damp but not dripping. Then wipe it across your face in small circles. The makeup should come off as you go.
The cloth has two sides. One side is softer for removing makeup. Flip it over and you’ll find a slightly textured side that gently buffs away dead skin cells while cleaning.
Getting the Best Results
Warm water works better than cold. It helps open your pores and makes the cloth more effective. Use circular motions instead of just dragging it across your face. This helps the fibers really grab the makeup.
Rinse the cloth after each use and let it air dry. Wash it in your machine every few days to keep it fresh and working properly. A clean cloth removes makeup better than a dirty one.
Real Makeup Eraser Reviews: What Users Are Saying
I wanted to know what happens when real people actually use this thing. So I looked at reviews from bloggers, moms, and regular makeup wearers. Here’s what they found.
Every day Laura’s Experience
Laura came across the Makeup Eraser while looking for ways to cut down on waste.
She tried several sizes: the mini, original, glove, and jumbo versions.
Her takeaway? It actually removes makeup well. She loved that one cloth replaces tons of disposable wipes. Better for the planet, easier on her wallet.
But here’s the catch she found. You have to wash it often. Like, really often. If you let it sit dirty for too long, it can cause breakouts. The cloth traps all that makeup and oil, so keeping it clean is non-negotiable.
JK Style’s Review
As a busy mom, she needed something quick. No time for a ten-step routine when the kids are calling.
She put it to the test by checking her face with micellar water after using the cloth. The cotton pad came back clean, which meant the Makeup Eraser actually did its job.
She takes it when traveling now instead of packing bottles of remover. And she doesn’t feel guilty about throwing away wipes anymore.
Cool Mom Picks’ Review
This family tested it together, including their teens. Everyone agreed the cloth feels soft and nice on the skin. They liked the little tag that shows which side is which.
The one issue? Heavy waterproof mascara put up a fight. It came off eventually but took more work than regular makeup.
Still, they said it beats buying disposable wipes over and over. One cloth does the work of hundreds of cotton pads.
Makeup Eraser vs. Traditional Makeup Removers
Let’s see how the Makeup Eraser stacks up against what you’re probably using right now.
Makeup Wipes
Wipes are super convenient. Grab one, wipe your face, toss it. Done.
But here’s the thing. You’re throwing away money and creating trash every single day. A pack of wipes costs around $5 to $10 and lasts maybe a month. The Makeup Eraser costs about $20 but lasts for years.
Wipes also contain chemicals and preservatives. The Makeup Eraser uses just water.
Cotton Rounds and Micellar Water
This combo works great for removing makeup. You have control over how much product you use.
The downside? You’re buying two products instead of one. Cotton rounds add up in the trash bin. And you need to keep restocking both items.
With the Makeup Eraser, there’s no extra product to buy. Just water from your sink.
Regular Washcloths
A washcloth is cheap and reusable. Seems like a good option, right?
The problem is the fabric. Regular washcloths don’t have the same microfiber technology. They might spread makeup around instead of actually removing it. Plus, they can feel rough on sensitive skin.
The Makeup Eraser is softer and specifically designed to grab makeup particles.
Cleansing Balms
Balms are amazing at breaking down makeup, especially waterproof stuff. They feel luxurious and really do the job.
But they cost more over time. A good cleansing balm runs $15 to $40 and you need to replace it every few months. You’re also adding another step since you still need to rinse thoroughly.
The Makeup Eraser is a one-and-done situation. No extra products, no extra steps.
The Bottom Line
Cost-wise, the Makeup Eraser wins long-term. You spend once and you’re set. For the environment, it’s way better than disposables. Convenience depends on what matters to you. If you want speed, wipes might feel easier. If you want simplicity, the cloth with just water is hard to beat.
Pros and Cons of the Makeup Eraser
Here’s what works well with the Makeup Eraser and where it falls short based on real user experiences.
Pros
- Removes most makeup using only water. No extra products needed.
- Reusable for years, which means way less waste than disposables.
- Soft texture that feels gentle on your face. Good for sensitive skin.
- Lasts 3 to 5 years with proper care. One cloth goes a long way.
Cons
- Struggles with waterproof mascara. You might need to go over it a few times.
- Requires frequent washing. A dirty cloth can cause breakouts.
- Costs more upfront than regular washcloths, though it saves money over time.
Conclusion
After reading dozens of reviews, here’s what I found.
Most people agree the Makeup Eraser works well, feels soft, and really does cut down on waste. It’s convenient and saves money over time.
But it’s not magic. You might still need a proper cleanser afterward, especially if you wear heavy makeup. Think of it as a great first step, not your entire routine.
Should you buy it? If you want to simplify your life and stop throwing away cotton pads every day, yes. It’s worth trying.
But if you love your current routine with balms and oils, you might not need it. For me, knowing it actually works and helps the planet makes it a solid choice.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the Makeup Eraser really remove all makeup with just water?
It removes most makeup types effectively using only warm water. However, waterproof mascara and heavy eye makeup might need a bit more effort or a second pass.
How often do I need to wash the Makeup Eraser?
Rinse it after each use and machine wash it every 3 to 5 days. Keeping it clean prevents bacteria buildup and breakouts on your skin.
Can I use the Makeup Eraser if I have sensitive skin?
Yes, it’s designed for all skin types including sensitive skin. Since it uses only water with no chemicals or fragrances, it’s gentler than many traditional makeup removers.
How long does one Makeup Eraser cloth last?
With proper care and regular washing, one cloth typically lasts 3 to 5 years. That’s thousands of uses from a single purchase.
Do I still need to use a cleanser after using the Makeup Eraser?
Many people follow up with a gentle cleanser, especially if they wear heavy makeup. The cloth removes makeup well but a cleanser ensures your skin is completely clean.
